The 2009 Golden Pen Awards: Suggestion Topic

[mr_pikachu]

Good evening, everyone, and welcome to the 2009 Golden Pen Awards! It's a pleasure to have you with us as we celebrate the finest accomplishments across Fanfiction during the past year.

Before we decide who is deserving of a prized Golden Pen, there's a bit of business that we need to address. First things first: the categories! It's up to all the members of Fanfiction to determine what categories are worthy of being in the Golden Pens. Below I've listed all the categories from the 2008 Golden Pen Awards. If you'd like to see some sort of change -- namely, an addition to the list, the removal of a category, or even a name change -- let us know in this thread! We'll deliberate over your suggestions and improve the list as such.

You have until 11:59 p.m. on Friday, January 8, 2010 to post your suggestions here. After the suggestion phase has concluded, we'll begin the nomination phase.

Now, here are the categories as they stand at present:



General Fic Awards

Best Fiction Overall
Best Fanfiction
Best Original Fiction
Best Short Story
Best Poem
Best E-zine Article
Best Plot
Best Dialogue
Best Narrative Voice
Best Description
Best Writing Style
Best Action
Best Setting
Most Original Fiction
Best New Fiction
Most Improved Fiction



Fic Moment Awards

Best Quote
Best Chapter
Best Plot Twist
Best Conflict
Best Moment



Character Awards

Best Character in a Leading Role
Best Character in a Supporting Role
Best Antagonist
Most Original Character
Best Romantic Relationship
Best Un-Romantic Relationship
Best Character Development
Best Cast



Member Awards

Best Writer
Most Dedicated Writer
Most Improved Writer
Best Reader
Most Dedicated Reader
Best Newcomer to the Boards



Now, let your voice be heard!

[Mew Master]

You know, as I look at the categories, I notice there are no Genre ones.

Things like:
Best Surreal
Best Dark Fantasy
Best Horror
Best Suspense
Best Science Fiction
Best Historical Fiction

That's also a very short "Best Moments' Category" I think.
Most Suspenseful Moment
Best Cliffhanger

Just a few ideas.

[Mewfour]

We need a Bloodiest/Most Violent fic category. I need to win something.

[Ultimate Charizard]

We need a Bloodiest/Most Violent fic category. I need to win something.

If that was in it might inspire me to resume writing Bloodbowl lol.

[Houndoom_Lover]

I want chicken wings soooo badly. Garlicx ones. I just had some last night :0 Whyyyyy?

It seems to me that we at once had a lot more..... Least likable character.

Character most likely to fail.

Strangest character.

Weirdest Plot Twist

Best use of cacon elements in a fanfiction...

Hmm...

[Mew Master]

Best use of cacon elements in a fanfiction...

Wow, I could actually win something with Ribbons with that category...

[Houndoom_Lover]

canon* :B I thought it be a good idea. I mean, anyone can write a fanfiction but useing the elements of that world so it seems flawless! That's fancy :B

[Mew Master]

The issue with that in some settings is that not everyone may know the elements of that world however. And won't know the difference between fan made and cannon events/people/organizations/ect...

Not everyone knows anything about Werewolf: the Forsaken like I do... so how do they know what I'm making up and what's part of the world?

[Houndoom_Lover]

I dunno, its called research. Whenever I read a fanfiction that I'm not certain about, I read/watch/listen to what its based on. On that note, people who read fanfictions are most likely reading it because they like what its based on, no?

^_^ But it was just a suggestion, nothing too serious and all.

[Dark Sage]

How about Best Battle Scene? Or Best Fight Scene?

I know this is a lot like Best Conflict, but a "conflict" is not always a fight.

[Mew Master]

I dunno, its called research. Whenever I read a fanfiction that I'm not certain about, I read/watch/listen to what its based on. On that note, people who read fanfictions are most likely reading it because they like what its based on, no?

And just how many people are un-lazy enough to do research on fic subjects they've never heard of? I know not many of my friends are -,-.... if any of them.

For Pokemon though, we're all familiar with a lot of those themes.

And I agree with Dark Sage. Best Fight or battle Scene should be considered.

[Lune the Guardian]

This is a great list. I like the "Best Fanfiction" and "Best Original Fiction" separation.

I don't see anything on the list that doesn't belong there, and I can't really think of anything that urgently needs to be added.

Nice work.

[Houndoom_Lover]

The Funniest Fanfic?

[mr_pikachu]

Thanks for your suggestions, everyone! Please be patient as we prepare for the Nomination Phase.