Alright, I’m going to ask that you please don’t take offense to what I have to say about your story. I’m not trying to be rude, offensive or hurt your feelings. Please realize that the only way to improve is to take criticism. The world is full of it, and there’s no way to escape it.
First: your general attitude of telling potential readers and reviewers to ‘back off’ isn’t wise. Opening up with hostility when absolutely nothing has been said will ward away people who could’ve potentially helped you.
I don’t know if you’re holding a grudge against certain people – but you shouldn’t let that paint a red hue over everyone.
Second: when you say “On a related please note if I had used the wrong word and had Charles be the one to ether say it or write it down please treat it as if I am implying that he has a Language-based learning disability, because clearly I been trying to establish that he is my likeness with every single flaw that I have including his heath issues among others.. -_-...”
In my opinion, that’s a poor attempt at an excuse to not having to check your spelling and grammar. For the most part, that can excuse when your character Charles speaks, because that is entirely up to you how he converses with other people – but when it comes to the rest of the story, the body of it and description – that won’t do.
My best friend has a learning disability: spelling and grammar are hard for her. However, she overcame the challenge of not understanding how and when you use certain words and punctuation. Now when she writes you can’t tell her writing from any other ‘normal’ person (I use the term normal because that is how you labelled the general populace in you introduction).
My point: stop hiding behind your language-based learning disability. If you want to improve, you’ll need to have the courage to ask others what word should be used or which form of punctuation. My friend I mentioned? All through school I was teaching her English and helping her out, and she’s improved tenfold. I ask mattbcl, samchu and ChobiChibi all the time for help with my writing, and it’s getting better.
You can overcome any challenge as long as you’re willing to ask for help, and implement the advice given.
Also – when you’re summing up your world and giving a brief background, I find it better to tie it into your story instead of making it a point by point statement before the actual story begins. If it’s written in character and describe well, there’s no need to list off facts about the world. You can also fit in facts about the world as you tell the story (as long as they tie into what’s going on), and have people learn about your island that way.
Now I’m no master of grammar like Mr. Pikachu or Gavin_Luper, but I can offer some advice. This list will also include just general little quirks I thought might need attending to.
(These tips are also brought to you by Samchu and ChobiChibi, as they helped me create my review)
1) You like to capitalize words in the middle of a sentence. For example: when you described Clair, you capitalized pretty. Pretty doesn’t need to be capitalized, only her name does. You do this from time to time throughout your story, just remember: you capitalize at the beginning of a sentence, a person’s name (this includes the names of species. Like Pikachu, Elites or Zerg), and a location’s name.
i.e – She stood out from the crowd due to her long, fire-engine red hair. With a smile she turned to the boy.
“My name’s Ruby, and welcome to Cinnabar Island!”
2) You tend to wander away from your points, in the beginning: Clair asks Leeks if Charles likes her, and while Leeks does say he thinks so… he then goes on about Clair’s father having a Lopbunny and presumably enjoying the colour pink (and getting forced into a dress by his wife). I’m assuming he made the connection between the two because maybe Charles likes pink or maybe he’s had a similar experience being forced into a dress, but… there was no context for the off-topicness. If that’s part of Leeks personality, you should state it somewhere so the readers know he tends to prattle on about unrelated things.
3) Charles and Clair have the same last name. This should probably be changed unless this story focuses around an incestuous couple.
4) You may want to explain somewhere in there as to why Leeks can speak like Meowth in the anime. Even just hinting at the tale behind it could entice readers to come back.
5) There are a lot of general errors like using the wrong word – you meant to use sweet but you put sweat instead (and you wrote exponent instead of experiment), you misspelled ‘Mayor’ a few times, etc. All of this can be fixed with reading over the story, having a beta-reader, or using spellcheck on various writing programs available. If you must, read over the fic a couple of times, or politely ask a friend to do so. Sometimes it’s hard to catch your own mistakes, but there’s ways around that.
6) My biggest suggestion is that you read your story out loud when you go back to edit it. You’ll take natural breaths and pauses, making where commas and periods should be. I found it difficult to read because there was no natural pacing to the story. It’ll become easier to read for your viewers and if it’s easier to process you might get more replies.
7) I was confused on the sacred texts; do they mention Ryu, Ryan and Skullfire outright? Because seeing as at least two of them are normal people (or implied as such), these ancient scrolls are not so ancient then. Otherwise, you may want to state in one of those final paragraphs that Charles has gone back to recent history and is not still reading the scrolls. And if Ryu and Ryan are actually some sorts of immortal beings, you may not want to mention them having just spoiled one potential future plot twist.
Positive note: You put a lot of work and thought into your world, and you’ve kept posting this story despite the drama that’s been haunting you in the fanfic forum. I give you credit for keeping at it, and I hope that you continue to put that sort of determination forward when it comes to spelling/grammar and future endeavours. You have a lot of room to improve, and I hope you do.
That final statement about expecting this story to still be here when you wake up is just rude Charles. As I said, curb your attitude or no one in this forum is going to be willing to help you.