An artistic opinion. (please read)

[Mew Master]

I offer a question to you all. Out of the following picture, which symbol for fire do you think is more aesthetically pleasing? A or B? My Roomate brought this up and I'm unsure which looks better as they each look fairly good.

So what do you all think?

Here

Other symbols I've come up with so far. Plan to have two more later.

EDIT: 1-07-09

Air
Earth
Water
Light
Shadow
Shaman
Alchemy
Conjurer
Vitali

Okay so those were the Affinities that I managed to get done. Here are the Aspects I have finished.

Elemental Aspect - Combines Fire, Water, Air,and Earth.
Illusion Aspect - Combines Light and Shadow
Invoker Aspect - Combines Shaman and Conjurer
Weaver Aspect - Combines Alchemy and Vitali

Well I suppose it's time to put everything into context. These symbols are going to have a use as you'll see with the following pic:

Elemental Magi Array - The description here pretty much explains the circular patterns of previous images. The other reason I'm leaving them mostly black and white is because there is going to be some glow effects around them, so the design has a reason to be simple without any color. So it's easier to manipulate in Photoshop for glowing patterns without having to worry about color.

Fire Magi Wiccard Blare and Dragon Familiar Brianna Kíash (Warning: Mild Nudity) - The description pans it out, but this is one of the few works I've ever done where I'm so surprised at how well it turned out, I can't stop looking at it. Now the Magick Array under Wic's feet shows you what I was planning for these symbols (at least for the four Elementals anyway). You can also see that I went with Option A. The reason I did so was that through various people, both picks came up about 50-50, so it was down to me to decide which one to use for this piece. I chose A because it felt more complete when I looked at them both. The two flares in the fire seemed to give it a sense of completion.