I like RE4, but it's certainly not much of a horror game. However, that could change with the upcoming reimagining, that has been the subject of hearsay the past couple of years.

I don't like how villagers drop ammo. That makes no sense. No way is that meant to creep you out.

Having a vendor selling you stuff, also took away the horror feel that older RE games did splendidly. But hey. To each their own, I guess.