Well, the other Pokemon I could have guessed there is one I already have a plushie of (Wooper), so naturally my first Pokemon choice when I'm making a guess and have some information, is generally one I don't have yet (my collection has over 300 plushies, just for the record).
Still, thanks Rossymore, that's a new one for me.
Here's the next puzzle.
------- (7)
Incorrect Guesses: n/a
Guesses Remaining: 9