Hey, here's a few dumb ideas:
Considering that the amount of Yu-Gi-Oh! fics seems to be increasing and the amount of Poke-fics seems to be decreasing (or at least staying pretty much still), why not add 'Best Yu-Gi-Oh! Fic' to the General Awards, 'Best Duel' to the Fic Moments, and 'Best New Card' to the Characters Section? I'm sure there would be a few good nominations for those categories...