So, is Professor Oak the smartest of all the professors?

[chanveil]

It seems most hold him in high regard and consider him the best. But I am not sure if everyone agrees with that.

[Deadwood_Zen]

Elm. Fo' sho'.

[Mikachu Yukitatsu]

Professor Ivy is more beautiful!

[Drago]

I agree on the Elm front. I really can't remember him from the anime at well, but the dude looked smart, didn't he? Oak preceded Elm and likely most other professors, hence he gets all the accolades.

...I can't believe I'm actually seriously discussing this. Where did my life go wrong?

As an aside, Elm reminds me a little bit of FMA's Shou Tucker.

[Austrian ViceMaster Alex]

I say Professor Oak but don't really have anything to base it on except that he and his work and achievements are simply better known and documented as he just appears more often than the others.

[Lady Vulpix]

I think Oak is the most famous, and his radio show helps him maintain his fame. He may be the oldest of them too. I'm sure he's good, but I find Bill most impressive; and he's usually not even counted as a professor. Maybe because he's not named after a plant.

[The Blue Avenger]

Wasn't Oak a student of Rowan's? Then Rowan would likely have the edge in terms of experience.

[Deadwood_Zen]

In the original Gold Version, Oak gave major props and huge respect to Elm. I might be a biased opinion, though, since I am a huge Johto fan.

[Dryk]

I roll old school, so I have to go for Oak. I just think that he had the knowledge nad the awesomeness to be the bomb. And I've been reading the manga lately, and he's a champion there.

[Telume]

Honestly, Oak to me just seems like the smartest.

[Magmar]

Professor Oak, the original, and the guy who had the best starters.

[Blademaster]

Birch.

...I like to root for the underdog.

[TryingTyrants]

Let's see...

Elm was so careless as to let a pokemon get stolen;
Birch got chased by a poocheyana (SP);
Rowan left his briefcase lying around;
And I've yet to play BW


So Yeah, Oak is.

[Cinnamon Grahams]

I think Aragari is the smartest.
Why?

She's a girl

[Cirrus]

I like Oak the best because while he discredits himself on inventing the Pokedex, he does seem to know what he's talking about. Elm's mind is all over the place and he doesn't pay attention much. Birch is meh.

Even though I can't understand anything she says, I like Arargi, as well.

[StevieDeEevee]

Oak is wise but with age comes wisdon so it might be between him and Rowan

[Constellar]

Nah I think Professor Rowan is smarter. He even shoots Oak down in one episode of the anime because he is lazier than he is.

[Deadwood_Zen]

The 'smartest' people are never really all there. When you have such a powerful mind, you tend to want to think more, then worry about 'measly' social encounters.

Elm ftw.