Results 1 to 21 of 21

Thread: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

  1. #1
    Elite Trainer
    Elite Trainer
    Charles Legend's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2003
    Location
    Ringwood, Marshiso
    Posts
    2,724

    Cool Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    Ok I am a were that we already have two topics about the G/S/C but seeing how there both old and dead I thought I'd post a newer one. Sorry ^_^:

    Anyways here is my thoughts, yes there should be a remake of the G/S/C games, I say this however not just for the fact my G/S/C internal batteries have died, but I would like to see it in better graphic and a some what flushed out plot.

    So here my Ideas

    Ok now lets say when we save the Jahto Radio tower we get the clear bell like in Crystal now then you may ask your self how do we get the Silver and rainbow wings then?

    Well what if for the silver wing you need to catch Moltres, Zapdos and Aricuno in that order, but were would they be you might ask the Sevii Islands.

    Moltres on Mt. Ember however you need the “Red Feather” given to you by like a Fire breather who found it in Victory Road that is after you bat them in a battle.

    Zapdos: Perhaps a new Island with something like Mt. Thunder on it and you need the Yellow Feather” given to you by the manager of the Power Plant as thanks for retuning the part that Rocket grunt stole since Zap Cannon is not a TM anymore.

    Aricuno: Perhaps a new Island with something like say Snowtop Mountain
    on it and you need the Blue Feather” given to you by a Swimmer ♀ that standing on the remains of the Seafoam Islands, have to beat her fist.

    Now then once you have the titans of Fire Ice and lighting in hand go to the Whirl Islands but wait what is this a tower named the “New Brass Tower” is in the spot were Lugia stood now what do we do? What else go in an and beat all the sages and the lead Sage well say that you have shown that you indeed are worthy of the to take the Silver Wing.

    Now then don’t think all your hard work was for nothing for now lets take a look at how to get the legendary beast shall we?

    Now then like in G/S/C you wake up the best in the basement of the Burnt tower, however like in Crystal Suicune runs around you before running off.

    And like in Crystal you meat Suicune several times, but you well only be able to face it In the Tin Tower once you catch both Entei and Raikou.

    Here how after you beat the Elite four insert a FR/LG into your DS and turn it on and go talk to blue standing on Cinnabar and he says something along the lines of "Three years ago an Entei roomed Kanto I guess it was born when this Volcano erupted." Then when he leaves Entei Appears and bastes a opening into the side of the Volcano and it goes in so you have to go in after it batting wild Slugma, Magcargo and the like until you find Entei and it well challenge you to a fight and once you catch it, leave but the cave will remain.

    For Raikou go back to the Power Plant and talk to the Manager and he well oppen up a door that leads to the secret cambers where wild electric pokemon are and Raikou is in the chamber that Zapdos used to be in

    Now then once you catch all three beast the Stares to the rest of the Tin tower appears now what’s this even more Sages?! Well beat them all up to earn the Rainbow wing from the leader.

    Oh grate now you have the Silver and Rainbow wings but if Lugia and Ho-oh are not at the Whirl Islands and Tin Tower where the hell are they you ask, Answer is quite simple there at Navel Rock.

    To get to at Navel Rock what you need to do is go back to the bament of the Burnt Tower and Eusine well be waiting for you beat him and he well you the Mysticticket, and say something along the lines of a friend of his that works for game frak gave him it however do to the fact he did not have the Silver and Rainbow wings nothing was on the Island.

    So yeah I know it wont happen but it makes the requirements for getting Lugia and Ho-oh a bit more tougher pulse it makes reference to the fact that Lugia and Ho-oh are the trio masters of the birds and the beast.

    now on to my replies


    Quote Originally Posted by mr_pikachu
    And I can see loads of possible features for a GSC remake. I'd like to see the Sevii Islands remain, and perhaps they could add a closer adaptation of the Orange Islands or something. (What can I say, I've wanted that for years.) Maybe that would offer further opportunities for encounters with the mysterious Red, too.

    I dunno; I'm probably dreaming here. Still, I always loved the prospect of visiting the Orange Islands. Badges++!
    funny you should say that Brian I was thinking of doing that for a fic, besides there is stuff in the FR/LG Bata that shows they were planing to make more Islands it's funny really since if they had made 24 Islands that you could goto in the games pulse the event Islands Navel Rock, Birth Island and Faraway Island that would make 27 Islands all together the same amount of islands as the Orange Islands has.

    And as as I stated above it would be cool if they made it so that your required to catch the Titans of Fire Ice and Lighting to get the Silver Wing so that it follows a some what similar plot to the movie, I mean it was kind of a let down that all you need to get Lugia was the Silver Wing and not that you need the birds to get the Silver Wing to get Lugia.


    Quote Originally Posted by Stupid People
    GSC was nothing more then a experiment, and that Kanto ruined Johto.
    ROFL,first of all so what if it was an experiment at lest it did not turn on it's creators and destroy them like Mewtwo did.

    Well I would not go that far the main reason behind a smaller Kanto was purely do to the fact the the technology was more useless then a level 100 Magikrap. which explains why they had to down grade the maps take for example the Lake of Rage the bata for it shows that there was going to be a town there which could have very well been Blackthorn, since Lance is reading the sign and as we all know Lance and Claire are cousins and that we never see him visiting Blackthorn his home town but just the Lake of Rage what's up with that?!


    Quote Originally Posted by Roy Karrde
    They should take out the stupid Underground crap to save space, however if they do the Underground again then they need to make it useful which I do have a idea for Add in a Unown element, have you dig up pieces to the Unown puzzle which you can use to unlock more areas

    They should also put in the Orange Islands, by doing that they could use the touch screen and MIC for badge trials in the Orange Islands. Like using the Touch Screen to aim your water pokemon to shoot down the discs. Or blow into the mic to have your character go down the mountain faster on the bobsled while steering them with the touch screen.
    While do agree digging up the Spheres is Annoying you do get rare Items such as fossils from the underground, I could see them having all three Kanto fossils, since there were no Johto Fossil Pokemon >_> and there should also be wild Pokemon in the underground and that you are required to use a few HMs such as flash, Straight, Dig (that actually is used to digs stuff out of the walls and ground not be a free escape rope thought it could be an option.), Rock Smash and Rock Climb. now I like your Idea of digging up Unown Puzzle pieces perhaps there could be a story behind them like say that the puzzles, the ruins of Alpha the Tanoby Chambers and the Solaceon Ruins are all the relics of Pokélantis but like the King was evil so Ho-oh had somoned an Aura Guardian to defeat the evil king.

    a much simpler answer would to expand the Sevii Islands which is basically the game counterpart to the Orange Islands, like I said they could use the plot of the movie 2000 nhell they could even throw in New Island and have Mewtwo there

    And like he says something along the lines of "I was not Born a Pokémon I was created and my Creators used and betrayed me thus I stand alone!" however instead of fighting and catching Mewtwo you fight him as if he was a trainer, and he sends out his own team of Pokemon consisting of Pikachu, Meowth, Venusaur, Charizard, Blastoise, Rhyperior and he says this after you beat him "Now I see, it dose not matter how you were born but what you do with the Gift of Life, here take this old Sea chart it well lead you to Mew." then Mewtwo goes on to explain the following "My Creator Dr. Fuji found Mew on Faraway Island and that he cloned me from it's DNA so that he could find out how to bring his Daughter Amber back to life."

    LOL J/K but that wold be kind of nice to make a refrence the the Animé plot lines some what, and I'll give an Oreo to the first person to guess why Mewtwo team is like that and why he did not evolve his Pikachu and Meowth but the rest of his team are fully evolved.

    ~Charles Legend
    Last edited by Charles Legend; 23rd May 2008 at 10:11 AM.

  2. #2
    Master Trainer
    Master Trainer
    Pokemaster Ash's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2000
    Posts
    5,741

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    Well I would certainly love to see a G/S remake (especially if they release it before the 5th gen). I'd say try to keep it a bit true to the originals, but here's what I wouldn't mind seeing added on:

    Sevii Islands included (possibly catch Articuno, Zapdos, Moltres there)
    Able to catch Celebi (GS Ball item, naturally)
    Lugia & Ho-oh at Whirl Islands & Tin Tower (something else can be at Navel Rock)
    Possible inclusion of Hoenn? (24 Badges would be more impressive than 16)
    The return of the Apricot Balls (though not taking as long to manufacture)
    Lots of Move Tutors (kinda like in Platinum)
    Gym Leader Rematches (it would be nice to see Bugsy with a REAL team)
    NO PokéRadar (not that it would be needed, G/S/C had almost everything pretty readily available)
    Actual effort put into the music (FR/LG's soundtrack could have been much better)

    ...well, that's all I can think of right now. I'm sure there's probably something else I'm forgetting at the moment...
    Last edited by Pokemaster Ash; 6th December 2008 at 01:09 AM.

  3. #3
    Ultimate Virtual Pokémon Advanced Trainer
    Advanced Trainer
    Poryhedron's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2003
    Posts
    1,898

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    Here's something I want: I want the people working on the GSC remake to consult the people who worked on GSC. Every time I play Fire Red I want to strangle the trainers whose quotes have been horribly mangled from their original version.

    Example: "Don't get me wrong, I love fishing. But it'd also be good if I had more work."
    You're seriously telling me nobody at NOA got the joke in a fisher saying "I'd rather be working"!? I need to go down there and slap some people.

    Example: "You know what they say about Sailors and battling!"
    Why, no, no I don't. I know what they say about sailors and fighting, though.

    Example: "I'm a rambling, gaming du—ghukghkl"
    /squeezes harder/


    Poryhedron's Monotype Challenges
    Winner of the 2007 Pokéhelper Unown Award! Glad I could be of help!
    Pokémon GO: Level 37, Team Mystic

  4. #4
    Veteran Trainer
    Veteran Trainer

    Join Date
    Sep 2002
    Location
    The Fanfiction Forum
    Posts
    19,535

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Poryhedron View Post
    Example: "I'm a rambling, gaming du—ghukghkl"
    /squeezes harder/
    But gambling is bad for the kiddies! No child should ever hear about such a terrible thing. Why, that's almost as bad as cockfighting!

    ...Yeah. In all fairness, a proper GSC remake would be totally awesome; personally, though, I just hope that if it happens, it has a faster movement speed than DP. That's my only real gripe with generation four, but really it gets in the way. I'm pretty sure DP's even more vast than GSC was (despite being one region instead of two), but it'd still be irritating to play through the doubled space with lag.
    IT HAS RETURNED.
    THE TPM MAIN SITE.

    Quote Originally Posted by Gavin Luper View Post
    Holy crap ... I'VE become a grammar nazi, too.

  5. #5
    why wub woo Moderator
    Moderator
    Heald's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2000
    Location
    cloudsdale, equestria
    Posts
    9,031

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    NOA is possibly the most evil organisation on this entire planet, and ought to be destroyed at any cost.
    Quote Originally Posted by Lady Vulpix
    You have turned my vacation thread into a discussion about Heald's balls. You should be ashamed of yourselves.




  6. #6
    Ultimate Virtual Pokémon Advanced Trainer
    Advanced Trainer
    Poryhedron's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2003
    Posts
    1,898

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    It's not the fact that they tried to censor out gambling that gets me. It's that they did such a piss-poor job of it. "To live is to play games"? Come on, guys, I know there's at least one brain among you.


    Poryhedron's Monotype Challenges
    Winner of the 2007 Pokéhelper Unown Award! Glad I could be of help!
    Pokémon GO: Level 37, Team Mystic

  7. #7
    Banned
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    177

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    There won't be a new GSC because then the people who got all pokémon in emerald would have caught all pokémon for nothing..
    it would remove all the balance..
    they could reintroduce it with new starters..

    and btw
    Quote Originally Posted by Charles Legend View Post
    The return of the Apricot Balls (though not taking as long to manufacture)
    In crystal they took long to manufacture but you could have like 99 a time if you had enough Apricorn thingamajigs..
    Last edited by Zallarion; 8th December 2008 at 09:14 AM.

  8. #8
    Ultimate Virtual Pokémon Advanced Trainer
    Advanced Trainer
    Poryhedron's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2003
    Posts
    1,898

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by need2knowonething View Post
    There won't be a new GSC because then the people who got all pokémon in emerald would have caught all pokémon for nothing..
    That's not true. You can transfer pokémon from 3rd Gen to 4th Gen, but not from 4th to 3rd, so the people who got all pokémon in Emerald have achieved exactly what they were trying to achieve at the time. Completing the National Dex in Emerald. A GSC remake won't help with that any.


    Poryhedron's Monotype Challenges
    Winner of the 2007 Pokéhelper Unown Award! Glad I could be of help!
    Pokémon GO: Level 37, Team Mystic

  9. #9
    Elite Trainer
    Elite Trainer
    Charles Legend's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2003
    Location
    Ringwood, Marshiso
    Posts
    2,724

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by need2knowonething
    There won't be a new GSC..
    LOL and what makes you so sure there won't be? you also misunderstood the whole point of this topic, I made it to get Ideas for what to put into my hack which is a G/S/C remake called Pokemon StarlightCrystal.

    Quote Originally Posted by need2knowonething
    In crystal they took long to manufacture but you could have like 99 a time if you had enough Apricorn thingamajigs..
    You misunderstood me once again, All I meant was that if a G/S Remake dose happen they should allow you to give Kurt 99 Apricorns...

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    Well I would certainly love to see a G/S remake especially if they release it before the 5th gen.
    Yeah thats what I think might happen as well.


    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    I'd say try to keep it a bit true to the originals
    Well I wold like to see it changed I mean ok the story remains the same as it was in Crystal with a few changes fist Eusine in the game and plays a big role and is battled more then once...

    However as far as a the mapping and events go I would like to se some stuff from Fr/Lg Remain usable such as the Safari Zone and the Cerulean Cave and Viridian Forest.


    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    Sevii Islands included possibly catch Articuno, Zapdos, Moltres there
    I agree that the Sevii Islands should remain, and my Ornial Idea Moltres is on Mt. Ember, Zapdos ether in the Viridian Forest or Berry Forest, and Articuno ether in the Seafoam Islands or Icefall Cave.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    Able to catch Celebi GS Ball item, naturally[
    True, they could also add faraway Island for Mew, for Jirachi use smash the rock in Mont Moon Square. Shaymin it's found at Flower Paradise which can be found by placing Oak's Letter on a white rock found in Bill's Secret Garden, which is like the trophy Garden has Pokemon in it, eevee being a common sight in it.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    Lugia & Ho-oh at Whirl Islands & Tin Tower (something else can be at Navel Rock)
    Actually I already covered this to get Ho-oh catch the Legendary Beasts, then fight the elder at the top of the tin Tower for the Rainbow Wing, for Lugia catch the Legendary birds, then beat the elder in a New Brass tower deep with in the Whirl Islands for the Silver wing, then you fight Eusine in the basement of the Burnt Tower and after which he gives you the Mysticticket. thus Lugia and Ho-oh are at Navel Rock, it makes a lot of since to have Lugia and Ho-oh be cough this way since they are Trio Masters thus more powerful then their underlings.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    Possible inclusion of Hoenn? (24 Badges would be more impressive than 16)
    No what they should do is have the Orange Islands, and the Orange League, also there could be for example some wild pokemon such as Munchlax on the Seven Grapefruit Islands.


    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    The return of the Apricot Balls (though not taking as long to manufacture)
    maybe make it so you yust have to walk out the door like you with fossils, also you should be able to give Kurt mor then one like you do in crystal.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    Lots of Move Tutors (kinda like in Platinum)
    yes, also make some more ajustments to the move sets such as having farfetch's learn Leaf Blade, also have Magikarp learn Dragon Rage at Level 20. just before it evolves.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    Gym Leader Rematches (it would be nice to see Bugsy with a REAL team)
    Agreed, like you get their Phone number.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    NO PokéRadar (not that it would be needed, G/S/C had almost everything pretty readily available)
    Agreed, Swarms on the other hand I could see happing.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    Actual effort put into the music (FR/LG's soundtrack could have been much better)
    Err dose not matter that much.

    Quote Originally Posted by Poryhedron
    Here's something I want: I want the people working on the GSC remake to consult the people who worked on GSC. Every time I play Fire Red I want to strangle the trainers whose quotes have been horribly mangled from their original version.
    Only if Kantho not all Squashed up, actually I did not mind the FR/LG quotes,

    Quote Originally Posted by mr_pikachu
    Yeah. In all fairness, a proper GSC remake would be totally awesome; personally, though, I just hope that if it happens, it has a faster movement speed than DP. That's my only real gripe with generation four, but really it gets in the way. I'm pretty sure DP's even more vast than GSC was (despite being one region instead of two), but it'd still be irritating to play through the doubled space with lag.
    for all we know Brian the Creaters may have planed for the Sevii Islands way back in the Orgnal Red and green, I mean we do know Leaf was planed to be playable back then. I don't mind the fact that did reconed some stuff in FR/LG in fact I don't realy count the R/B/Y games any more, since FR/LG take there place.

    [color=wheat one of the things that bugs me is when People make a hack of G/S/C they just revamp the Pokemon and trainer Sprites, instead of making newer ones, well when it comes to the Pokemon anyways.

    ~Charles Legend
    Last edited by Charles Legend; 13th December 2008 at 04:54 PM.
    ASB VS Seeker Profile

    “If at first the idea is not absurd, then there is no hope for it.” ― Albert Einstein

    "The computer world is like an intellectual Wild West, in which you can shoot anyone you wish with your ideas, if you're willing to risk the consequences." --from Hackers & Painters: Big Ideas from the Computer Age, by Paul Graham

    "To build a story world, the author must be part artist, part engineer, and sometimes part mad scientist.." --from Fundamentals of world building by Jessie Verino

    “Let food be thy medicine and medicine be thy food.” - Hippocrates


  10. #10
    Cloyster Moderator
    Moderator
    Jeff's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    Maryland, USA
    Posts
    4,453

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    OK, here's my idea. The remakes should be called Pokemon Brass and Tin.

    Both versions should have a fully fleshed out Kanto. Bring Viridian forest back to its full glory for example, the gimped representation of it we got in GSC was a disappointment, as were most of the other things in Kanto. Cinnabar should be left destroyed, since that was part of the plot, but add a cave to it, maybe even put Heatran in it.

    Brass should be similar to the original games story-wise. It'll center around the burned brass tower where three pokemon died and were resurrected by the game's central legendary Ho-oh. All the major events will play out like they did in gold; after visiting the burned tower, you'll be able to find the beasts running around Johto.

    In Tin, the story will center around Lugia, and will have some big differences from Gold, Silver, and Brass. At the beginning of the game, both towers will still be standing, but a battle between the three legendary birds from Kanto moves into Johto and they accidentally burn the Tin Tower. Reports abound around the Johto region that a large white bird stopped the fight. When you get to the burned tower, you'll notice that Articuno, Zapdos, and Moltres are asleep in its base, and when you go up to them they fly off and start roaming Johto. Lugia will now be residing in the Brass Tower, and you can go in and catch it after getting the Silver Wing, which you get just as you did in Silver. After getting the Rainbow Wing in Pewter City, you can catch Ho-oh at an all-new location in Johto. Maybe the summit of Mt. Mortar or something.

    That way, those looking for nostalgia, and those looking for something new both have something to make them happy.
    Winner of the Unown Awards: 2008 "Hard Work", 2010 "Dedicated", 2012 "Journalist", 2012 "Unown", 2013 "Anchorman", 2014 "Unown", 2015 "Jeff Jeff Jeff Jeff!"



    Facebook - YouTube - Miiverse
    Diamond: 1418 3196 1413 - SoulSilver: 0217 4582 5426 - White: 1119 9535 7054 - White 2: 1421 4560 4887 - X: same as 3DS
    3DS: 3866 8018 5231 - AIM: IslanderJeff02
    Joined November 8, 2004 - Modded October 24, 2008

  11. #11
    Master Trainer
    Master Trainer
    Pokemaster Ash's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2000
    Posts
    5,741

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    Eh, I'd rather keep it simple like FireRed & LeafGreen did if they did a remake. First off, keep Gold and Silver in the titles (Brass and Tin aren't exactly high-quality metal, after all). And I'd say just not mess with the Legendaries all that much. Keep Lugia and Ho-oh where they were at Whirl Islands and Tin Tower, leave the Beasts alone (though maybe give them a final destination where they stay after a certain amount of running around and can be battled normally). Like I said, having the Sevii Islands and Hoenn would be a plus since you could pick up those Legendaries and more badges and stuff (at the very least this helps those who are starting out in the 4th gen). Those wanting the Orange Islands, remember, that was an anime-only arc and not canon elsewhere (if you can really say there's a canon to the games or manga, though G/S/C tried). Would be nice to see Viridian Forest and some of those other places that got taken out in the originals restored.

    Besides, it would be nice to battle all the other PCs and Rivals (Red, Blue, Green, Gold/Crystal (whoever you're not playing), Silver, Brendan, May, Dawn, and Lucas, to use the default names) as an extra challenge on top of that. I don't think I want to see the Battle Frontier again, though...

  12. #12
    Elite Trainer
    Elite Trainer
    Charles Legend's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2003
    Location
    Ringwood, Marshiso
    Posts
    2,724

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Jeff
    OK, here's my idea. The remakes should be called Pokemon Brass and Tin.
    Actually DuskGold and DawnSilver make better names.

    Quote Originally Posted by Jeff
    Both versions should have a fully fleshed out Kanto. Bring Viridian forest back to its full glory for example, the gimped representation of it we got in GSC was a disappointment, as were most of the other things in Kanto. Cinnabar should be left destroyed, since that was part of the plot, but add a cave to it, maybe even put Heatran in it.
    Agreed and thats what I was getting at, The Volcano eruption can still take place, however I could see the buildings remain with Burnt roofs like the Brunt Tower.

    Quote Originally Posted by Jeff
    Brass should be similar to the original games story-wise. It'll center around the burned brass tower where three pokemon died and were resurrected by the game's central legendary Ho-oh. All the major events will play out like they did in gold; after visiting the burned tower, you'll be able to find the beasts running around Johto.

    In Tin, the story will center around Lugia, and will have some big differences from Gold, Silver, and Brass. At the beginning of the game, both towers will still be standing, but a battle between the three legendary birds from Kanto moves into Johto and they accidentally burn the Tin Tower. Reports abound around the Johto region that a large white bird stopped the fight. When you get to the burned tower, you'll notice that Articuno, Zapdos, and Moltres are asleep in its base, and when you go up to them they fly off and start roaming Johto. Lugia will now be residing in the Brass Tower, and you can go in and catch it after getting the Silver Wing, which you get just as you did in Silver. After getting the Rainbow Wing in Pewter City, you can catch Ho-oh at an all-new location in Johto. Maybe the summit of Mt. Mortar or something.

    That way, those looking for nostalgia, and those looking for something new both have something to make them happy.
    Actually I like that Idea, ok so DuskGold plays out just like Gold dose, and DawnSilver can have Tin's Plot.

    Ok So in DuskGold Lugia is on the roof of a new Brass Tower, and in DawnSilver Ho-oh is on the roof a new Tin Tower
    both of which are located on a new Island in the center of the Whirl Islands, which can only be gotten to by going threw the cave the exit being where Lugia sits in G/S/C...


    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    Eh, I'd rather keep it simple like FireRed & LeafGreen did if they did a remake. First off, keep Gold and Silver in the titles Brass and Tin aren't exactly high-quality metal, after all.
    Sure If Game freak ever did thet mostly would make it simple which in truth is what makes the games som what boring, as for the Titles DustGold and DwanSilver make for good titles.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    And I'd say just not mess with the Legendaries all that much. Keep Lugia and Ho-oh where they were at Whirl Islands and Tin Tower, leave the Beasts alone (though maybe give them a final destination where they stay after a certain amount of running around and can be battled normally).
    Ho-oh and Lugia are semi Event Pokemon thought which is why, I'm all for Increasing the requirements for getting them namely having both the wing and the Trio they are masters over!

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    Like I said, having the Sevii Islands and Hoenn would be a plus since you could pick up those Legendaries and more badges and stuff (at the very least this helps those who are starting out in the 4th gen).
    Look Ash I'm Only going to say this once, Hoenn will not be in a G/S/C remake end of Story! However I agree that the Sevii Islands should remain.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    Those wanting the Orange Islands, remember, that was an anime-only arc and not canon elsewhere (if you can really say there's a canon to the games or manga, though G/S/C tried). Would be nice to see Viridian Forest and some of those other places that got taken out in the originals restored.
    True in an Official game they most likely won't be however they are still cannon, Look at it this way we know the Sevii Islands are cannon well seeing as the FR/LG Bata shows that they were planing on making more islands, besides the Animé that Shows the Orange Islands and New Island being under the Sevii Islands which are based off two archipelagos off the coast of Tokyo: the Izu Islands (伊豆諸島) and the Ogasawara Islands (小笠原諸島, so it is likely that the Orange Islands are also based off of them.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    Besides, it would be nice to battle all the other PCs and Rivals (Red, Blue, Green, Gold/Crystal (whoever you're not playing), Silver, Brendan, May, Dawn, and Lucas, to use the default names) as an extra challenge on top of that. I don't think I want to see the Battle Frontier again, though...
    I don't Know, I can see Gold/Crystal having the third Starter after Sliver steals the one stronger to yours, Red is found at Mount. Silver, Blue is the gym leader of Viridian City Gym, Actually instead of the Battle Frontier why not have the Viridian City Trainer House bge more useful like say battle threw Easter Egg Trainers such as Leaf, Lucas, Dawn and Pearl to get to Cal whose look is redone slightly so he not a clone of Gold.

    ~Charles Legend
    Last edited by Charles Legend; 13th December 2008 at 04:47 AM.
    ASB VS Seeker Profile

    “If at first the idea is not absurd, then there is no hope for it.” ― Albert Einstein

    "The computer world is like an intellectual Wild West, in which you can shoot anyone you wish with your ideas, if you're willing to risk the consequences." --from Hackers & Painters: Big Ideas from the Computer Age, by Paul Graham

    "To build a story world, the author must be part artist, part engineer, and sometimes part mad scientist.." --from Fundamentals of world building by Jessie Verino

    “Let food be thy medicine and medicine be thy food.” - Hippocrates


  13. #13
    Master Trainer
    Master Trainer
    Pokemaster Ash's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2000
    Posts
    5,741

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    Okay, maybe not Hoenn (come to think of it, would it even fit on the cart if they tried with D/P's graphics?). I still say they should try to get as much terrain as they can in there. And okay, if you're going to restrict access to Lugia & Ho-oh, I suppose the least that could be done is keep it simple. Maybe catch all 3 birds to get the Silver Wing and all 3 Beasts for the Rainbow wing? I guess Faraway Island could be snuck in for Mew, and naturally find a way to get the GS Ball in there for Celebi (and naturally both items really damn hard to get but not impossible, I'm tired of Event Items). But if Lugia & Ho-oh are back to their normal locations, what do you put at Navel Rock?

  14. #14
    Elite Trainer
    Elite Trainer
    Charles Legend's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2003
    Location
    Ringwood, Marshiso
    Posts
    2,724

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    Okay, maybe not Hoenn (come to think of it, would it even fit on the cart if they tried with D/P's graphics?). I still say they should try to get as much terrain as they can in there.
    the reson for not wanting Hoenn is they may some day get their own remake... I agree with get as much terrain as they can in there. maybe by adding a few more routs maybe gotten to threw a mine at Cianwood City..

    Quote Originally Posted by Pokemaster Ash
    And ok, if you're going to restrict access to Lugia & Ho-oh, I suppose the least that could be done is keep it simple. Maybe catch all 3 birds to get the Silver Wing and all 3 Beasts for the Rainbow wing? I guess Faraway Island could be snuck in for Mew, and naturally find a way to get the GS Ball in there for Celebi (and naturally both items really damn hard to get but not impossible, I'm tired of Event Items). But if Lugia & Ho-oh are back to their normal locations, what do you put at Navel Rock?
    Increasing the Requirements dose not mean restrict access to Lugia & Ho-oh, it Simply means having their trios being caught.. -_-; Now your just reping what I saif in my First post. in my hack I was planning on the Old Sea Chart being found in the Tree of Being where the four Regis guard it as well as Puzzles like the ones found in the Ruins of Alpha, for the G/S ball maybe have kurt forage it from the Silver, Rainbow wing and like a Gold Apricorn, which on ther own could be made into a Mater Ball. I don't know which is why I originally said you need the Beast, Birds, aWings and the Mysticticket to get them at Navel Rock...

    ~Charles Legend
    ASB VS Seeker Profile

    “If at first the idea is not absurd, then there is no hope for it.” ― Albert Einstein

    "The computer world is like an intellectual Wild West, in which you can shoot anyone you wish with your ideas, if you're willing to risk the consequences." --from Hackers & Painters: Big Ideas from the Computer Age, by Paul Graham

    "To build a story world, the author must be part artist, part engineer, and sometimes part mad scientist.." --from Fundamentals of world building by Jessie Verino

    “Let food be thy medicine and medicine be thy food.” - Hippocrates


  15. #15
    You crook! Ya CRIMINAL!! Veteran Trainer
    Veteran Trainer
    Blademaster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    The Universe - 46 degrees north, 8 trillion degrees west
    Posts
    12,589

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    Is this thread about an official GSC remake or about your to-be-made game, Charlie? 'Cuz if it's the former, you're getting a bit too bossy about it.

    (Nintendo) 4 Lyfe





    HEY! I do art commissions! Follow me and my pals on their website here!

  16. #16
    Beginning Trainer
    Beginning Trainer
    peetzaman's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Posts
    10

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    If you would like my opinion on who/what the remakes are about, just look at my sig. 8D

  17. #17
    You crook! Ya CRIMINAL!! Veteran Trainer
    Veteran Trainer
    Blademaster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    The Universe - 46 degrees north, 8 trillion degrees west
    Posts
    12,589

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    ^That's actually a pretty cool idea. Silver was a thief, and the possible son of Giovanni. It'd be nice to see him get a backstory and-

    Fuck, who am I kidding? This is an RPG - the plot never changes. Only the characters (or the character names, if you wanna be cynical) do. -_-

    (Nintendo) 4 Lyfe





    HEY! I do art commissions! Follow me and my pals on their website here!

  18. #18
    Master Trainer
    Master Trainer
    Pokemaster Ash's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2000
    Posts
    5,741

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    I think it's actually official that Silver is Giovanni's son at this point. I think it's mentioned in the manga, and a Team Rocket scientist in FireRed/LeafGreen mentions Giovanni has son whose description does match Silver to a degree.

  19. #19
    Elite Trainer
    Elite Trainer
    Charles Legend's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2003
    Location
    Ringwood, Marshiso
    Posts
    2,724

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    I agree, now moving on do you guys think they well Incluse stuff such as the Gold/ Silver Leafs and the Brick Peice I mean it would be nice to atally have a Sprite of them.

    I was also thinking since they did all those alternate forms, what if this time around the Slowpoke's Tail was not useless but changed Shellder into it's spiral Fourme, which normaly is attachted to a Slowpoke, I mean think about it Shellder's spiral Fourme has teeth and it says in I thin a dex about Slowking that when a Shellder bit's Slowpoke's head it injects it's brain with toxins, it sounds to me like it's using Poison fang on Slowpoke, it could use Ice fang, thought like Rotom it would loss the move if Shellder is not holding a Slpwpoke's tail... LOL DX and while in Sprail Forme the water stone could have no effect on Shellder.

    ~Charles Legend
    ASB VS Seeker Profile

    “If at first the idea is not absurd, then there is no hope for it.” ― Albert Einstein

    "The computer world is like an intellectual Wild West, in which you can shoot anyone you wish with your ideas, if you're willing to risk the consequences." --from Hackers & Painters: Big Ideas from the Computer Age, by Paul Graham

    "To build a story world, the author must be part artist, part engineer, and sometimes part mad scientist.." --from Fundamentals of world building by Jessie Verino

    “Let food be thy medicine and medicine be thy food.” - Hippocrates


  20. #20
    Beginning Trainer
    Beginning Trainer
    Coontank!'s Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    Connecticut, USA
    Posts
    8

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    I think it would be awesome to bring the phone feature back in a 2nd gen remake, but make it connect to Wi-Fi. So you could "call" a friend in your Pad Pal (I'm thinking of something that would work like instant messaging) and challange them to a battle or request a trade if they're within Wi-Fi range. Or leave them a message if they're not within range or if their DS isn't turned on. So the Friend Code would be like a phone number. It would make trade coordinations a ton easier. Although I have no idea how something lack that would really work from a technical aspect lol

  21. #21
    Rl #32:Enjoy The Little Things Master Trainer
    Master Trainer
    Shadow Wolf's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Puerto Rico
    Posts
    5,610

    Default Re: Official 2nd Generation REMAKE Thread

    Well, I have thought that Raikou and Entei should deserve a chance to be the game's main pokemon. However, I'm not sure about a proper title for the games(Pokemon Amber for Raikou and Pokemon Jasper for Entei...that sounds kinda crappy to me)

    Speaking about features of GSC, The Radio on GSC should have something useful, like something to play real music, or just hear any of the soundtracks of the games, animes, or anything like that. That way, the radio card could be useful.

    Plus, if they made a plot between Groudon and Kyogre, and probably about Dialga and Palkia, why not make a plot between the three legendary "dogs" and the three legendary "birds" or between Ho-oh and Lugia.

    Ugh, my brain is wasted. I'll think of other ideas some other time.


    Optimist award 2012.

    “There is nothing better than a friend, unless it is a friend with chocolate.” (Linda Grayson)

    Thank you everyone... for being so kind and for bringing out the best in me! You are definitely awesome! ^_^

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •