The Daily News

[Roy Karrde]

Suppose the man is mentally ill. Does he deserve to die then?
Suppose the man is homeless and only needed money to feed his family - and made a poor choice. Does he deserve to die then?
Hell, let's get really weird - suppose the man's being blackmailed into threatening you. Does he deserve to die then?

All of the answers to those are yes, the man has threatened your life, he walked up and basically got into the mindset of "Its either me or him". You do not have time to play a guessing game. You either take action, or you yourself basically forfit the claim on your life as well as the ones around you.

My mentality would change greatly if I were switching my gun away from a sheet of paper and towards a living being. The training would be useless at that point.

At the point that you have to actually pull your gun out, at that point you are running on so much adriniline and going on the mindset of killing this person. That the training you have will pretty much guide your body.

A claim to one's life is something that can never be lost.

Yeah it is, when he steps toward you and points a gun at you, he has gotten into a "Me or You" mindset. He has lost any claim to his life when he decided to try and take yours for money.

To think otherwise is barbaric:

To act in any other way is stupidity and reckless.

Shooting the guy in the knee or the arm holding the gun should be sufficient.

Problem with both is you are risking the chance of him shooting you back, especially if you do not aim to kill. Hesitation will cost you your life, and could cost you the lives of others. That man is coming at you to kill you, not doing the same is utter stupidity.

Overpowering and subduing him should be a responsible gun-owner's top priority, not mercilessly gunning him down in cold blood.

Well for one if the man is pointing the gun at you that is not cold blood that is self defense. Second the top priority of any gun owner at that time should be killing him. Becuase giving him any chance to shoot back at you, gives him a chance to kill you. And as I said, the others around you. Trying to subdue or overpower him, shows a lack of responsability and judgement on your part, and it puts the lives around you on the line.

[Blademaster]

All of the answers to those are yes

At the point that you have to actually pull your gun out, at that point you are running on so much adriniline and going on the mindset of killing this person.

Yeah it is, when he steps toward you and points a gun at you, he has gotten into a "Me or You" mindset. He has lost any claim to his life when he decided to try and take yours for money.

To act in any other way is stupidity and reckless.

That man is coming at you to kill you, not doing the same is utter stupidity.

Well for one if the man is pointing the gun at you that is not cold blood that is self defense. Second the top priority of any gun owner at that time should be killing him.

Becuase giving him any chance to shoot back at you, gives him a chance to kill you. And as I said, the others around you. Trying to subdue or overpower him, shows a lack of responsability

I'm taking my leave from this argument now. You're displaying some very disturbing behavior in these answers, and if you truly believe that even slight criminal provocation of any kind is grounds for murdering the provoker, you need help and you need it fast.

[Roy Karrde]

You're displaying some very disturbing behavior in these answers,

The only disturbing behavior is your lack of willingness to defend your own life and the lives around you. God I would hate to be one of your loved ones if it came down to you defending them.

and if you truly believe that even slight criminal provocation of any kind is grounds for murdering the provoker, you need help and you need it fast.

Putting a gun in your face is not slight criminal provocation it is a attempt to murder you. Saying anything less shows a lack of rational thought on your part. You need help, or you need to lock yourself away from anyone else in society, so that your own stupidity does not harm anyone else.