SAW 5 or HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL 3?

[PancaKe]

Just wondering, have you seen them all?

If he thinks they suck, I would assume he HADN'T indeed seen them all. Therefore, making that statement an uninformed one. If he'd seen all of them, and still thought they sucked, well nvm me then.

[Zak]

If he thinks they suck, I would assume he HADN'T indeed seen them all. Therefore, making that statement an uninformed one. If he'd seen all of them, and still thought they sucked, well nvm me then.

I don't know what you're trying to say, but it doesn't make sense because usually saying "they all suck" would hopefully mean that he HAS seen them (at least one) because then it would be fair judgement, unlike Dru here who claims it "relies on gore" followed by a claim that she hasn't seen it.

EDIT: Oh, I see what you're saying. If he had seen one and thought it sucked, then of course I wouldn't expect him to see them all. But I asked if he'd seen ANY of them, not necessarily ALL of them. Because he'd look like a bandwagon idiot if he said that "they all suck" without having seen ANY of them. You get what I am saying here?

BTW hi Tara

[PancaKe]

I don't know what you're trying to say, but it doesn't make sense because usually saying "they all suck" would hopefully mean that he HAS seen them (at least one) because then it would be fair judgement, unlike Dru here who claims it "relies on gore" followed by a claim that she hasn't seen it.

EDIT: Oh, I see what you're saying. If he had seen one and thought it sucked, then of course I wouldn't expect him to see them all. But I asked if he'd seen ANY of them, not necessarily ALL of them. Because he'd look like a bandwagon idiot if he said that "they all suck" without having seen ANY of them. You get what I am saying here?

BTW hi Tara

Yeah I get what you're saying. Haha I guess I was just typing my thought process as I was thinking it, not after I had thought it through to see if it actually made sense!

BTW HI ZAK WHOMG I MISSED YOOOU!!!1!!11!@#2!!!1!one