SAW 5 or HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL 3?

[Andrew]

Saw is a movie franchise that relies heavily on the gore factor in order to keep the audience shocked and/or titilated. Other such ones include Hostel, Chainsaw Massacre and The Hills have eyes.

While the original Saw was a shocking modern classic in it's own right the subsequent sequels have diminished it's originality and reduced the public perception to shock gore.

So, saw is a subgenre of the horror genre. Just not a particularly engaging one for people like myself.

Personally, psychological/zombie/supernatural horror are much more favoured by myself. Ie - The Ring and the 1st half of Dawn of the Dead remake.

[Zak]

Saw is a movie franchise that relies heavily on the gore factor in order to keep the audience shocked and/or titilated. Other such ones include Hostel, Chainsaw Massacre and The Hills have eyes.

While the original Saw was a shocking modern classic in it's own right the subsequent sequels have diminished it's originality and reduced the public perception to shock gore.

So, saw is a subgenre of the horror genre. Just not a particularly engaging one for people like myself.

Personally, psychological/zombie/supernatural horror are much more favoured by myself. Ie - The Ring and the 1st half of Dawn of the Dead remake.

Saw might have a lot of gore, but it doesn't rely entirely on it. Don't even compare it to that shitfest that is Hostel, and certainly not the Hills Have Eyes. Yes, it's gross, but I think nowadays more people go see it for the plot twist/puzzle aspect of it rather than the gore. At least it's not the same story over and over again, the plots of each of them vary.

Though it's true none of them live up to the suspense factor of the first one, but as for me, I watch it to try and guess the end and come up with crazy theories as to what's gonna happen in the next one, like with Harry Potter. I know it sounds like a odd comparison, but to me, and to a lot of people I know who like it, both online and offline, the anticipation level is about the same and they like it mainly for that, not necessarily the gore. In fact I don't know anyone who watches it for gore.

I bet more than half the money Saw V makes won't be because of gore, but because of fans of the franchise who actually want to know what happens rather than see more gore.

There's also the creative trap designs that keep people interested, but most of them admire the traps themselves rather than the gore that happens in them. If that makes any sense, though I'm pretty sure you know what I'm getting at.

But Hostel? The Hills Have Eyes? Hell, even Friday the 13th is repetitve, I actually gave the first three a chance. and got bored by the same story every time, a bunch of people at a camp get killed by Jason, one person survives and beats him.


But anyway, one more reason I have high hopes of part 5 being better than 2-4 is because it's got a new director who's FAR better than that of 2-4. And, I saw a few preview clips and it looks like it's gonna live up to the first one. Of course I won't know for sure until Thursday night, but I'll post what I thought of it. And it won't be biased, because I'll say right now I actually hated most of Saw 4, found it to be really weak.


But as for zombie movies/supernatural horror being better, and what Sam said above... well, can't really argue, to each his own I guess. I think it's much more interesting when it's something that CAN happen, ever see Misery?

[PancaKe]

You know what, I'm thinking I'll change my vote from the rusted spork to High School Musical 3, just because it been left out of discussion.

Probably for a very good reason, but anyhoo.

I should probably watch it, because I have a bunch of 14 year old girls who will come up to me and tell me how adorable Zak Effron is (yuck.)

[Zak]

Zak Effron

It's Zac Efron. Don't disgrace "Zak"s like that.

[PancaKe]

It's Zac Efron. Don't disgrace "Zak"s like that.

Lmao. Sorry for disgracing your name.

[kendawg528]

i don't see what's so wrong about HSM3. the songs are really corny but catchy, and the mood is so damn happy that it's contagious.

[Zak]

i don't see what's so wrong about HSM3. the songs are really corny but catchy, and the mood is so damn happy that it's contagious.

It's more "so wrong" to release it on the same day as Saw V.

[Blademaster]

Though it's true none of them live up to the suspense factor of the first one, but as for me, I watch it to try and guess the end and come up with crazy theories as to what's gonna happen in the next one, like with Harry Potter. I know it sounds like a odd comparison, but to me, and to a lot of people I know who like it, both online and offline, the anticipation level is about the same and they like it mainly for that, not necessarily the gore. In fact I don't know anyone who watches it for gore.

I bet more than half the money Saw V makes won't be because of gore, but because of fans of the franchise who actually want to know what happens rather than see more gore.

There's also the creative trap designs that keep people interested, but most of them admire the traps themselves rather than the gore that happens in them. If that makes any sense, though I'm pretty sure you know what I'm getting at.

^This. The creativity in the SAW movies, both in terms of plot and, shall we say, plot instruments, is something that makes me think and keeps my interest.