Quote Originally Posted by Cynder View Post
1. These, if I'm going to be honest, aren't even technically revamps. They're just recolours of old sprites using new colours, you can tell by the fact that the old shading is intact, and the outlines aren't shaded at all.

2. Technically, a revamp is a sprite made to look like the new ones, size and proportion wise as well as shading, so it's got to be mainly scratched over the old sprite truth be told. Anyway, I'd say that the Ampharos is probably the best of the lot, since it look a little more natural, but the shades could do with a little more contrast. Did you make them yourself?
1. Actually, they were made totally white, bar the outlines (which I tried to make totally black, bar maybe Flareon, which I can't remember doing) and I shaded them myself.

2. Since when!? Back in my day, you used the original outline and changed the shading >:I

I agree with you, mostly, on the rest. It's been a bit too long for me to totally remember what I did to comment back, but thanks for the critique!