
Originally Posted by
Roy Karrde
If you wish to do your own analysis of the Bureau of Labor Statistics report be my guest.
good idea
Men
Code:
Year Percent of Group Population Employed
1990 72.0
1991 70.4
1992 69.8
1993 70.0
1994 70.4
1995 70.8
1996 70.9
1997 71.3
1998 71.6
1999 71.6
2000 71.9
2001 70.9
2002 69.7
2003 68.9
2004 69.2
2005 69.6
2006 70.1
2007 69.8
2008 68.5
2009 64.5
2010 63.7
2011 63.9
Women
Code:
Year Percent of Group Population Employed
1990 54.3
1991 53.7
1992 53.8
1993 54.1
1994 55.3
1995 55.6
1996 56.0
1997 56.8
1998 57.1
1999 57.4
2000 57.5
2001 57.0
2002 56.3
2003 56.1
2004 56.0
2005 56.2
2006 56.6
2007 56.6
2008 56.2
2009 54.4
2010 53.6
2011 53.2
women lost 3.0% over 2008-2011 versus men losing 4.6%
women lost 1.2% over 2009-2011 versus men losing 0.6%
women lost 1.5% over 2000-2004 versus men losing 2.7%
women lost 0.5% over 1990-1992 versus men losing 2.2%
as a consequence of the coincidence of global macroeconomic factors and western gender roles, for decades the trend has been that the permanent loss of (male-oriented) full-time manufacturing jobs is much more likely than (gender-neutral) losses in part-time service employment.
is the 2009-2011 period particularly indicative of an obama 'war against women'?
consider that the devastating turn of events in the 2008-2009 period (4% of men, 1.8% of women) sloughed off nearly all the disposable men, and the rest of the losses were not especially gender biased (in the service sector). in turn, the recovery for men began earlier (men gained 0.2% over 2010-2011) - almost certainly found through the vast surplus of such labour then available in the american market. the recovery of jobs for women has not really happened yet, and has been steady at around 52.9-53.4% (seasonally adjusted) since 2010. perhaps it will only remain steady at the 'new normal'.
this is being manipulated into rhetorical use against obama. on examination, it is fairly unconvincing. but it warrants questioning as to what is planned for the recovery, not merely the stagnation, of the female labour force.